© Scotwork NA

The $5,000,000 Comma

Published: Mar 02 , 2018
Author: Brian Buck

Had my high school English teacher told me that a comma could cost me $5,000,000, I would have paid far more attention! I’m sure that’s what the Oakhurst Dairy company is thinking after it had to settle a dispute over the placement (or misplacement) of a comma.

How many times do we reach verbal agreements or come to terms with another party but never stop to fully document what we’ve agreed to? It happens more often than you think. In fact, I suspect that had Oakhurst Dairy and its drivers accurately documented the true intent of the exemption clause, Oakhurst Dairy could have potentially avoided the $5M mistake.

How do you know if you are doing this well or not? Take this quick assessment:

  1. What percentage of your deals change scope, price, and/or deal terms when you go from what’s been verbally agreed to contract? (0 to 100%)
  2. What percentage of your deals see fundamental changes to scope, price, and/or deal terms during fulfillment of agreement due to misunderstandings? (0 to 100%)
  3. What percentage of your deals wind up being partially or fully disputed after the agreement has been contracted? (0 to 100%)

Add all of your percentages together. The closer you are to zero the greater the likelihood that you are doing an excellent job at documenting your agreements and ensuring all parties are on the same page. The further you are from zero, particularly if you exceed thirty total percent, you might have an issue with how you document your deals.

Some quick and easy tips:

  • Deal with discrepancies in the room. Once you’ve agreed to a deal, recap what you’ve agreed to and ask everyone if anyone has a different understanding. This gives you the ability to deal with the discrepancy in the room while memories are fresh.
  • Send an email recap. Before going to something more formal, send an email to recap the deal and what you’ve agreed to. Some find this very useful before going to a contract.
  • Ask for clarity. Don’t be afraid to ask for clarity if you don’t understand or don’t feel you’re on the same page with the other party. Better to get clarity now instead of fighting about it later.

Don’t let something like a comma derail your entire deal.


Brian Website Headshot 2.png

About the author:

Brian Buck
Sure, we could whip up a snappy bio about Brian’s experience as an entrepreneur, business owner, and Fortune 500 executive. While we’re at it, we could go on for an afternoon about his 20 years in marketing and advertising, developing brilliant consumer-engagement strategies for the likes of Google, Amazon, Samsung, Virgin Mobile, Microsoft, and Sony. But knowing Brian, he’d rather we not. Instead, he’d likely ask us to focus on something else — namely, other people ...

Read more about Brian Buck

More posts by Brian Buck

Latest Blog:

Stranger Things Have Been Known to Happen

Of all the media and fan sites dedicated to probing every nuance of Netflix’s must-watch series Stranger Things, the experts might be missing something obvious but rather profound. I’m not a big TV or movie buff, but certain themes and genres tend to excite my interests more than others, and this show definitely represents one of them. Yet while so many journalists and bloggers have focused on the minutiae, they seem to have glossed over the extraordinary — namely, the line that separates the believable from unbelievable. Personally, I’m amazed by the creative minds that come up with such fantastical ideas. It’s truly a unique gift and a point of instruction to take with you to the negotiation table.

Latest Tweet:

Scotwork North America
400 Lanidex Plaza, FL 2
Parsippany, NJ
United States
Follow us