
If you’ve been reading these articles for a while, you know I love Thanksgiving: the food, the family, the friends, the football. But this year, I realized I’ve carried an assumption for a long time: I host Thanksgiving.
Years ago, a holiday strategy fell into place: I’d take Thanksgiving, and my sister-in-law would take Christmas. I don’t remember anyone deciding it so much as we landed there, and it became our tradition — and our constraint.
There are possibilities we’ve never explored. Maybe my sister-in-law would like to cook the turkey. Maybe we’d go to New York for the Macy’s Day Parade. Maybe we’d host Christmas, and I’d make a prime rib, or we’d all go somewhere snowy. None of that gets considered, because the question never comes up.
I started wondering whether my constraint was limiting new memories. Most of the constraints we all operate within are inherited. Think about the ones at work: “Legal will never approve that.” “The boss wants it done this week.” “They won’t go below 20 percent.” These may originate from something that happened once, or a few times, and were repeated often enough to harden into a rule. Nobody checks whether it’s still true or was ever true.
I was reminded of this recently. We were working on a project for a client, and the team came up with an idea that would genuinely help them. I got excited and mentioned that we had a meeting with the client the following Monday. We could show it off then, if we wanted to. In my head, I was offering a possibility, not a directive. That isn’t how it landed.
Without my knowledge, the team started moving heaven and earth to be ready by Monday. All we really had was an idea, not the strategy behind it; they were debating how to fill in the blanks while the clock ran down. Nobody wanted to be the reason we missed the delivery date.
Then someone finally asked me how firm the Monday deadline was. I asked where the deadline came from. They pointed at me. In my excitement about the idea, I’d put the emphasis on the date and almost none on the “if we wanted.” And because we work on tight turnarounds, the team heard “business as usual.” I’m glad they asked, because what I meant and what they heard were two different things, and it was a good reminder to be more careful about how I say things.
The part that stayed with me was that nobody wanted to look like they couldn’t get the job done.
Constraints may be inherited, but the reason we don’t test them is personal: We’re afraid of the answer, so why bother asking? The constraint isn’t really what’s holding us in place; the story we tell ourselves about asking is.
The cost isn’t just a stressful week or a deal term we gave away. It’s everything we never considered, because we never asked the question that would’ve opened it up.
Which brings me back to Thanksgiving. I’ll be honest, I was nervous to ask. I love cooking in preparation for that day. I worried about what it would mean if everyone said yes, and I was also worried about what it would mean if they said no. But I took a deep breath and asked the question. Stay tuned for the answer . . .
What can your team do when there seems like there’s no room to maneuver? Examine the assumptions and the constraints that may be holding your team back.
Get in touch with one of our experts today.
Why is challenging assumptions important in negotiation?
Untested assumptions can limit your options before a negotiation even begins. Challenging them helps distinguish genuine constraints from expectations, habits, or outdated information, creating opportunities that might otherwise go unexplored.
How do I identify hidden assumptions in a negotiation?
Look for statements that sound absolute: “They’ll never agree,” “We can’t change that,” or “This has to happen by Friday.” Ask where the constraint originated, who established it, and whether it still applies.
What’s the best way to challenge an assumption without creating conflict?
Lead with curiosity rather than disagreement. Questions like “What makes that deadline necessary?” or “Under what circumstances could that change?” invite explanation without putting the other side on the defensive.
What if the other side refuses to reconsider a constraint?
First, understand why the constraint matters. It may reflect a genuine requirement rather than an assumption. If it can’t change, explore other variables that could help both sides achieve their objectives.
Can challenging assumptions create better negotiation outcomes?
Yes. Questioning an assumed limitation can reveal flexibility around timing, scope, resources, or other terms. Even when the original constraint remains, understanding its rationale can help you develop more effective proposals.
By Brian Buck | 06.11.26
As a kid, I used to go to garage sales with my dad and watch…
By Brian Buck | 23.10.26
It’s zombie season, which seems like the right time to talk about deals that won’t…
By Brian Buck | 16.10.26
Recently, I helped a brilliant friend negotiate a job offer. He’s literally a rocket scientist….